Showing posts with label mussar. Show all posts
Showing posts with label mussar. Show all posts

Friday, October 15, 2010

The Measure of Success

I just got home from the doctoral organ recital of a very good friend of mine from high school, whom I had last seen ten years ago, when we were both undergrads. We had been roommates back in organ summer camp, and I would consider him as close a friend as I had. In these ten years, he has gone from an outstanding, competition-winning young organist, to (seemingly) building himself up as a world-class player. He always impressed me as a down-to-earth, humble person to boot. And he also introduced me to Monty Python.

I started thinking about this, and I must admit, I despaired a bit. What greatness have I achieved in the last ten years? Do I have any kind of bekius? Have I refined my personality to any great degree? Am I an outstanding father? No! Alas, what has become of me? Why have I failed when others, whom I was so close to, have succeeded so gloriously?

And then I continued to think. Indeed, one of my core traits is that I am a generalist. I thrive on achieving a basic level of competence in many areas; it's not in my nature to be "the best" at any one thing - my best is to be good at lots of things. I continued to think: just a second... in the last ten years, what have I done? I have learned a new language with its own alphabet totally different to what I grew up with. I know how to learn Gemara. I have taught myself web development. I have managed to do a halfway decent job of integrating myself into a new society which bears very little resemblance to what I grew up with, and am making strides in carving myself out a niche in it. I am raising three beautiful children!

Self-doubt be [beep]ed! I certainly cannot claim that I have realized my full potential, or that I never mess up. But to think that I have achieved less than my old friend just because his success is more apparent is an unforgiveable short-selling. I am making remarkable use of the tremendous gifts that God has given me in so many areas: analytical, linguistic, personal mettle... My path has lain in a totally different direction to his - and I am following it faithfully. That's the measure of success.

Wednesday, May 27, 2009

Bias

This week I've witnessed a powerful demonstration of personal bias, in myself.

I know nothing about biblical criticism. It happened that I started reading a blog post relating to an event in the Modern Orthodox world tangentially related to this phenomenon; the comments provided a lively discussion. On the mere suggestion of empirical evidence for heretical views of the Torah, I felt a significant challenge to my relationship with Torah and Hashem. I am recovering now; I don't know if this is because I'm particularly susceptible to suggestion (which I think is true), but it certainly jibes with what we learn from Rav Dessler et al.

I later went to Rav Hirsch's Collected Writings Vol. V to peruse his response to Frankel's writing on the Mishnah. I'm planning on waiting until I feel on firmer ground in my evolution investigations before I even consider looking into this one. I think rebbe guidance is even more strongly called for here.